QUESTION:
Do I have to show my work on
every problem? (Monthly practice work and on tests)
SHORT ANSWER:
Yes.
LONG ANSWER:
Uh...yeah. Well, if you
want to do well in math, that is. There are two basic
reasons why showing work--almost every step--is really vital in
math. More musing about it following the two reasons.
- To avoid little mistakes.
Too many times students do steps in their head, and such as
subtracting 17 to both sides of an equation, but actually
add instead of subtracting on one side---and if they had
actually written the -17 on both sides, their brain would
have realized that it was subtract, not add...and the
student would not have lost 3 or 4 or 8 points on a
test. Just a few of these kinds of a mistake on a test
and all of a sudden an A grade has turned in to a C, or a B
grade has turned in to a D.
- Checking answers:
- When practicing at home, if
students check an answer and sees it is wrong, how do they
know where they went wrong? How do they learn from
their mistake if they don't see where their mistake
was? Therefore, it's vital to write down every step,
to allow you to go back and analyze why you were
wrong...either a small calculation error, misplaced
decimal or negative sign, not doing a procedural step
correctly, or not realizing you just didn't know how to do
it. When you compare your steps to the steps in the
solution, then you will be able to learn from the correct
steps, and focus on the one or two things you did not do
correctly the first time. Learning those one or two
things will often mean a grade's difference on a
test. This happens a few times...that's the
difference between C and A, or D and B...if you really
learn from the mistakes, adding in good practice, study,
and memorization.
- When finished with a test,
you are required to come to get the test back and make
student corrections--meaning to analyze your errors,
correct the problem by showing step-by-step how to get the
correct answer, and writing a sentence saying what your
error had been (all that is 5% of your monthly
grade). It's pretty hard to do this if you don't
have the steps written out on the test from when you did
it the first time. Therefore, it's vital for you to
write every step to every problem, so you can look back at
it later to figure things out better, if needed.
OTHER MUSINGS:
- As a corollary to number 1
above, writing out every step when taking a test really can
help you keep focused on the procedures you have to do in
order to get the question right. In fact, sometimes
you might not be completely sure of the next step in a
problem--but if you see the previous step written down, that
sometimes jogs your brain to remember the next step.
If you don't write down a step, or you skip a step, then you
don't get this little reminder, and you probably look at the
problem blankly, and give up or go in a weird direction
rather than get it right.
- Also, not writing down steps
can lead to bad habits, such as misplacing decimal points in
your mind, or other little things. Remember that
education is not just learning information. It is also about
training your mind so you think well, and can figure things
out. Although you DO want to be able to do a lot of
things in your head, you also want to get the test questions
correct, and learn the material really well--and on long
hard math problems, you should not be thinking about saving
time or acting smart by doing things in your head...you
should be thinking about getting an A, and doing whatever it
takes.
- It is reasonable that not
EVERYTHING be written down. For students in middle
school and above, you are expected to know your
multiplication facts perfectly (though 12). Thus, I
don't expect you to have to write down 7•6=42. That
kind of stuff you should know in your head and should do
quickly and easily. It's writing down the steps in a
problem that I'm talking about...the steps that lead you to
an answer, and that you have a far better chance of getting
correct if you write them down and see them on paper rather
than trying to keep track of them in your head.